Paying off a loan early: shorter term or lower payment, and is the fee worth it?
You owe 200,000 at 6% a year with 20 years to go. You pay off 20,000 early with a 2% fee:
A bonus, an inheritance or a savings account that has just matured: putting it towards the mortgage is a natural thought. Before you do, two questions are worth answering: does the early repayment fee eat the benefit, and when the lender asks whether you want a shorter term or a lower monthly payment, which should you pick?
Example: 200,000 owed with 20 years left
A mortgage with equal monthly payments of 1,433, at 6% a year, with 240 months left. You pay 20,000 early and the lender charges 2% on it, which is 400. Then you choose one of two options:
- Shorter term: keep paying 1,433 a month as before, so the loan ends sooner.
- Lower payment: keep the 20 years and spread the remaining 180,000 over 240 months, so each payment drops to 1,290.
| No overpayment | Shorter term | Lower payment | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Next payment | 1,433 | 1,433 | 1,290 |
| Paid off in | 240 months | 199 months | 240 months |
| Interest still to pay | 143,856 | 104,162 | 129,408 |
| Interest saved | - | 39,694 | 14,448 |
| After the 400 fee | - | 39,294 | 14,048 |
Either way, the 2% fee is small next to the interest you save. See the repayment schedule without the overpayment →
What you still owe over time
Tap the chart to see the balance year by year.
A shorter term saves more, but is not necessarily better
The table shows the shorter term saving 39,694, well over twice the 14,448 saved by lowering the payment. That is not because it is the smarter option. With a shorter term you keep paying the full amount every month, so you put more money into the loan over the following years. More money into the loan means less interest, of course.
A fairer measure is the return: the yearly percentage of interest that the money paid early lets you avoid. Without a fee, both options return exactly the loan rate, 6% a year. With a 2% fee, the shorter term returns 5.9% a year and the lower payment 5.8% a year, almost the same.
So choose based on your cash flow:
- Steady income and you want to be debt-free sooner: shorter term.
- You want breathing room each month in case income drops: lower payment. If you later put the monthly difference towards the loan, you end up close to the shorter-term result anyway.
How big a fee is too big?
Paying early is like putting money into a risk-free savings account that pays your loan rate. The fee is paid once, up front, so the longer the loan still has to run, the smaller the fee is per year. The table below shows the return after the fee on a 6% loan, using the lower-payment option:
| Early repayment fee | Return after the fee (% a year), by years left on the loan | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 yrs | 3 yrs | 5 yrs | 10 yrs | 15 yrs | |
| 1% | 4.1% | 5.3% | 5.6% | 5.8% | 5.8% |
| 2% | 2.3% | 4.7% | 5.2% | 5.6% | 5.7% |
| 3% | 0.5% | 4.0% | 4.8% | 5.3% | 5.5% |
With 5 years or more left, a 1-3% fee only pulls the return down to 4.8-5.8% a year. With 1 year left it is a different story: a 3% fee leaves just 0.5% a year, often less than a savings account pays. If the fee drops or ends soon under your contract, waiting a few months can pay off.
Compare this return with what the money could earn if you kept it, for example in savings. If paying early returns more, it is the better use. On a variable-rate loan the real return follows the rate in the years ahead, so the higher rates go, the more paying early is worth.
Try it with your loan
Fee to pay: -
| Shorter term | Lower payment | |
|---|---|---|
| Interest saved | - | - |
| After the fee | - | - |
| Result | - | - |
| Return after the fee | - | - |
What to ask your lender first
- How the fee works: a percentage of the amount paid early or of the whole balance, and how it changes over the years.
- Free allowance: many lenders let you pay a set amount each year, often around 10% of the balance, without any fee.
- Whether you can choose a shorter term or a lower payment, or the lender applies one by default.
- Ask for the new repayment schedule afterwards and check it against the calculator above.
Do not use your whole emergency fund. Money paid into a loan is hard to get back when you need it, so keep at least a few months of expenses aside.
Frequently asked questions
How much is a typical early repayment fee?
Should I pay off my loan early or save the money?
Is it worth paying early during a fixed-rate deal?
Shorter term or lower payment: which is better?
Planning to pay off early?
The Fincal app works out every overpayment option for you, even offline:
- Multiple overpayments: one-off or regular, with fees, and see what you save
- Changing rates: an intro rate and then a variable one, as many periods as you need
- Save and compare: put your options side by side and pick the best