Flat rate vs reducing balance: which loan really costs more?
Both quoted at 12% a year, borrowing 10,000 for 12 months:
What is a flat interest rate?
With a flat rate, the interest is worked out on the full amount you originally borrowed, and it stays that way however much you have already paid back.
Borrow 10,000 at a 12% flat rate and you pay 100.00 in interest every month - even in the final month, when you only owe about 837.00. Flat rates turn up mostly on personal loans, car finance and store instalment plans.
What is a reducing balance rate?
A reducing balance rate (also called a diminishing or effective rate) charges interest only on what you still owe. Each repayment shrinks the balance, so the interest shrinks with it. It usually comes in one of two forms:
- Equal principal: you pay off the same slice of the loan every month, so the first payment is the largest and each one after is a little smaller.
- Equal monthly payments: the payment never changes. Early on it is mostly interest; towards the end it is mostly principal. Most mortgages and bank car loans work this way.
Interest each month
10,000 at 12% a year over 12 months. Tap a bar to see the amount.
The flat rate stays at 100.00 right to the end. On a reducing balance it is down to 8.00 by month 12.
Worked example: 10,000 at 12% for 12 months
| Flat rate | Reducing balance | Equal payments | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Payment, month 1 | 933.00 | 933.00 | 888.00 |
| Payment, month 12 | 937.00 | 845.00 | 895.00 |
| Total interest | 1,200.00 | 650.00 | 663.00 |
In month 1 the flat-rate loan and the reducing-balance loan cost exactly the same. The gap opens up after that: on a flat rate the interest never drops, even though your balance does. Open this example in the loan calculator →
Why does a flat rate cost almost twice as much?
When you repay in monthly instalments over a year, you only have about half of the money for the year on average. A flat rate still charges interest on the full 10,000 the whole time.
What is the interest charged on?
Bars show what you still owe at the start of each month. The dashed line is the amount the flat rate charges interest on.
So before comparing a flat-rate offer with a reducing-balance one, convert it to the effective rate: the reducing-balance rate that gives you exactly the same monthly payment. It is close to the APR lenders quote, although an APR may also include fees.
Flat rate to effective rate conversion table
| Flat rate | Effective rate a year, by term (months) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 | 24 | 36 | 60 | 84 | |
| 5% | 9.1% | 9.5% | 9.4% | 9.3% | 9.0% |
| 8% | 14.5% | 14.8% | 14.7% | 14.3% | 13.7% |
| 12% | 21.4% | 21.6% | 21.2% | 20.4% | 19.5% |
Rule of thumb: the effective rate is roughly 1.6-1.9 times the flat rate. There is no simple formula for the exact figure, so the converter below solves it for you.
Quick converter
How to spot a flat rate in a loan offer
- Flat rates are often labelled "flat rate p.a.", "add-on interest", or shown as a bare percentage next to a fixed monthly payment.
- Reducing balance loans usually mention "interest on the outstanding balance", "reducing balance" or an APR.
- The surest way is to ask for the repayment schedule and the total interest, then put them into the calculator to see the real rate.
Frequently asked questions
Is a flat rate ever the better deal?
Is a flat rate the same as a fixed rate?
Is 0% finance a flat rate?
What happens if I pay off a flat-rate loan early?
Weighing up a loan?
The Fincal app helps you compare before you sign, even offline:
- Flat rate converter: see the effective rate of any instalment loan
- Save and compare: put your options side by side and pick the cheapest
- Early repayment: include fees and see how much you save